During class I always welcome questions. It shows that the students are thinking about what they are doing, and, using their already gained knowledge, they can see alternatives. Brilliant stuff I think, in it’s place that is. What gets to me is when I have just demonstrated the technique that I want the students to practice only to turn round and find them doing something quite different. They then utter; “Why can’t I do it this way? Or “What’s wrong with doing it like this? Etc. You teachers will know exactly what I’m saying. The answer to most of those questions, generally, is; “Yes you can do it that way” or “No, there’s nothing wrong with that technique”, etc. BUT!!! THESE ARE NOT THE TECHNIQUES THAT WE ARE PRACTICING NOW!!!! Just do as your told until you get the mechanics of the thing first, then play with it to suit you and the varying heights, builds, speed, power, etc. of the various people that you partner up with. My reasoning for this attitude is mainly twofold. A) The student is to lazy (or whatever) to try something a bit more difficult B) they are struggling to work it against the person that they are partnered up with at that moment. That can easily go the other way when they change partners when the original technique now works. At this point some of you out there might be saying; “Well why not let them do that now with this guy, then change it for that guy?” NO!! They have proven to me that the technique that they wish to do instead is already with them. They already know how to apply it. Leave that one for the moment and practice a new skill. That’s why we are here. Most of the time they can eventually apply the new technique against almost anyone. If they would just persevere and get it right. What a lot of people seem to forget, especially the ‘Realistic Self Protection/Defence guys, is, this is training. We are trying to develop our skills. Widen our arsenal of techniques. All those guys that believe that you only need a couple of good techniques well practiced generally end up with a wake up call when ‘old faithful’ lets them down. It has happened to me. If all you have is a hammer, then every problem is a nail. You can’t pre-emptively strike everyone. You never always get the chance either. Try the techniques in class under controlled pressure, see how you do. This is the best place to make your mistakes, not the street. Regardless of how you train, everyone has a handful of favourite techniques anyway, but you still have a plan B should it all go wrong. And remember, you train WITH your partners, not ON them.
Please let me know your thoughts on this guys, as I still make mistakes too.
Paul.